May 3, 2023

Options Expiration vs. Exercising Options: Common Misconceptions

If you have spent any time researching trading schools or trading signal services, you undoubtedly have come across many that claim that buying options is a proposition that loses up to 90% of the time and thus you should always take the other side and sell options.  Sound great right?  Problem is that these claims are based on false premises.  Here is just one of the quotes I have found out there:

 “Over 75% of all options held until expiration expire worthlessly . . . That’s why you should do what the pros do and sell options to other people. After all, if most of them will expire worthlessly, why not collect some money for them today while they still have value?”

Here’s how the numbers break down according to the OCC (Options Clearing Corporation):

According to historical OCC statistics for the year 2015 (for activity in customer and firm accounts), the breakdown is as follows: 

  • Position closed by selling the option: 71.3%
  • Exercised: 7.0%
  • Held and allowed to expire worthless: 21.7%
This data from the OCC is accurate. So why do so many people believe that 90% of options expire worthlessly? Basically, it is a mistake in logical thinking.
 
It’s worth noting that open interest is measured only once each day. Let’s look at a simple example: Assume that a specific option has an open interest (OI) of 100 and that 70 of those options are closed prior to expiration. That leaves an OI of 30. If 7 are exercised and 23 expire worthless, then 77% of the open interest (as of the morning of expiration day) expires worthless. Those who do not understand this subtlety claim that so much of the open interest expires worthless.
 
The important thing to remember is that buying options have its time and place and selling options have its time and place.  Painting yourself into one corner or the other is a fool’s errand.
 

about the author:

Mike Shorr

Since 1994, Michael has been an on-the-floor market maker, Vice-President of Interest Rate Derivatives for Knight Financial Products and Director of Education and Options Instructor at Trading Advantage. He makes the oftentimes complex world of options and trading accessible to the novice and advanced trader alike. Michael has a Bachelor of Science degree in Statistics and Finance from the University of Illinois Champaign-Urbana. He presently is Director, Trader Education at ProsperTradingAcademy.

Read Similar Articles

https://www.prospertrading.com/3-stocks-scott-bauer-is-watching-this-week/3 Stocks Scott Bauer is Watching This Week
August 25, 2025

3 Stocks Scott Bauer is Watching This Week

Scott Bauer joins Diane King Hall on the Charles Schwab Network to share 3 stocks he’s watching this week.

Read Article
March 6, 2025

Options Trading Mistakes That Can Blow Up Your Account (And How to Avoid Them)

Options trading offers huge potential rewards—but it also comes with serious risks that can be mitigated. I’ve seen traders time and time again jump in without fully understanding the mechanics, leading to costly mistakes that wipe out their accounts overnight. President Trump’s new tariff policies are shaking up global markets, adding another layer of uncertainty […]

Read Article
December 6, 2024

The Broken-Wing Butterfly: A Hidden Gem in Options Trading

Options traders employ numerous strategies to achieve their goals in the market, and the broken-wing butterfly is a particularly useful technique to have at your disposal. This guide will explain the strategy in detail and show you how it can potentially be leveraged in various situations to take advantage of the market environment. Want My […]

Read Article

Read Similar Articles

https://www.prospertrading.com/could-supreme-court-tariff-ruling-send-the-market-soaring/Could Supreme Court Tariff Ruling Send the Market Soaring?
November 13, 2025

Could Supreme Court Tariff Ruling Send the Market Soaring?

All eyes are on the Supreme Court… How will they rule on the legality of President Trump’s tariffs? Some are going even deeper, and wondering how the SCOTUS ruling on this case could affect the market. Could the Supreme Court cause a market surge? Scott Bauer shared his thoughts on why this may (or may […]

Read Article
https://www.prospertrading.com/how-implied-volatility-affects-intrinsic-and-extrinsic-value-of-options/How Implied Volatility Affects Intrinsic And Extrinsic Value Of Options
November 11, 2025

How Implied Volatility Affects Intrinsic And Extrinsic Value Of Options

Implied volatility (IV) helps traders measure how much the market believes the price of an underlying asset will move in the future. What many traders don’t know is that Implied Volatility can play a key role in affecting the intrinsic and extrinsic value of options. These metrics can show how much more an in-the-money (ITM) […]

Read Article
https://www.prospertrading.com/panw-stock-weird-pattern-gives-charlie-moon-bullish-trade-idea/PANW Stock: Weird Pattern Gives Charlie Moon Bullish Trade Idea
November 7, 2025

PANW Stock: Weird Pattern Gives Charlie Moon Bullish Trade Idea

PANW Stock (Palo Alto) skyrocketed over 27% in the last three months. Despite dipping slightly after coming off a new high, Charlie Moon believes the stock could be positioning itself for a potential near-term price jump. His reasoning is based on a strange pattern he spotted in the stock’s chart last week. Charlie guest hosted […]

Read Article